I felt waves of cognitive dissonance on the drive to the trailhead. Driving toward Granite Falls, clear skies overhead, and Mt. Pilchuck silhouetted in the pre-dawn glow, I couldn't help but think it a early fall day. And yet, the calander read February...
The road up to Pilchuck has some pretty healthy potholes, but the highlight is a washout a few miles in. While still passable to cars, it will not have to get much worse before it starts weeding out Smart Cars and Priuses. There is also second, less severe washout developing shortly after the first.
I set up the trail just a few moments before dawn. The lower 1/3 of the trail has a few spots of mud, but was mostly in good condition. The first few peekaboo views revealed a lovely, clear day dawning below. It was so pleasant, so cool and crisp that it felt like October. And yet, the calander read February...
Breaking out into the open revealed a panoply of peaks bathed in the morning light, Three Fingers being front and center. From here on to the top, there were many patches of ice. Boots, poles and careful stepping would be enough to manage, but since I had my microspikes with me, I figured there was no point in not using them. Aside from these patches of ice, the trail was as clear as could be. It reminded me of hiking this trail in October, and yet, the calander read February...
The trail crossed over to the west face of the mountain, and the Puget sound lowlands, replete with patches of fog, were laid out below. Mt. Rainier could be clearly seen to the south, along with a porcupine of skyscrapers. The Olympics, the Whulge, Lake Stevens and Everett laid out to the east, and The Skagit could be seen to the north. Breathtaking.
After a final run of concrete-like, icey snow, the trail led me to the top. The summit was readily attained. I have stood there many times before, and taken in that vista, but this time there was something just so special, so wonderful about it. The sense of wonder reminded me of how I felt the first time I stood there. I lingered, and lingered, just gazing, just looking, just being. It was trascendant.
As I stood at the lookout, other hikers started to trickle in. One, upon climbing the ladder, thurned to me and said "Well, there's a first time for everything." Comprehending perfectly, I turned to him as said in unison, "February!"
I will admit, my mood was spoiled some on the was down by the appearance of the yokels. First was "jeans guy." Then came the couple in tennis shoes. Followed by the backpack-free crowd. And then, the newest of the breed, "selfie-stick yokel." There was an incredible stream of people headed up the trail, hiker and yokel alike, but it was the woefully underprepared folks that caused me concern. I'm sure that as the sun touched the horizon that evening there were still people in jeans and tennis shoes, headed across treacherous patches of ice, with neither a backpack nor the slightest clue of what the 10 essentials are.
Though it soured my mood some (I was tempted to start turning back those who were clearly lacking in sound judgment), it didn't ruin my day. The final vestigal views as the trail submerged into the forest helped, as did my resolve to do something mildly cathartic in this trip report. So here goes:
The following is not a rant (the rant is above, where I call people yokels). I am writing this out of genuine concern for your safety. People get lost and injured on the Mount Pilchuck trail with stunning regularity....during the summer. And, despite the general lack of snow and the unseasonable sunshine, it is still winter out there, which compounds the dangers for underprepared hikers with its attendant short days, cold nights, and potentially treacherous conditions. Here are some rules for winter hiking in the mountains:
- If you are thinking about heading out in tennis shoes, PLEASE DO NOT GO. Neon colored running shoes are included in this category.
- If you are wearing jeans, PLEASE DO NOT GO. The best dressed corpses wear cotton.
- If you are headed up in shorts and not carrying additional layers, PLEASE DO NOT GO. Unless you think you'd look good as popsicle.
- If you don't have the slightest idea of when sunset is, or how long it may take you to complete the hike, PLEASE DO NOT GO.
- If you do not know what the 10 Essentials are, and you are not carrying them, PLEASE DO NOT GO.
Study up, do your research, and make an informed decision as to whether your skills and equipment are up to the task. If you have any doubt, find an alternative destination. There are lots of great destinations that are more forgiving for the unprepared. Find a beach hike, front country hike, or nice river hike. Wallace Falls is nice. Ebey's Landing...great choice. Worst case, walk around Green Lake. If your heart is set on Pilchuck, wait until summer. The days are longer and the nights are warmer, so the probability of you being found alive when the inevitable happens are much higher.

Comments
Amen.
Amen to that "non-rant." I also was very concerned for the people headed up ill-prepared. I just never know if it's my place to say. The very last couple we saw heading up asked how long was the trip, we told them they would be heading down in the dark traversing patches of ice in an attempt to discourage them (it was already 3pm). One of them had shorts on, neither of them any supplies (except whatever may fit in their pockets). Their response? "Sounds rebellious!" Well good luck to them!
Posted by:
TRohn on Feb 17, 2015 12:36 PM
Jon Lee on Mount Pilchuck
And what is worse is that they probably made it back to the car ok, reinforcing their bad decision making. I have heard it called the illusion of experience. It is like the captain of the replica of the HMS Bounty, who took his leaky ship out to sea ahead of Superstorm Sandy. His mistaken belief that a "ship is safer at sea" (baloney, a ship is safer nestled in a protected harbour, with her crew ashore sipping hot buttered rums) was reinforced by making similar decisions in the past and surviving. This time through, he lost his ship, his life, the life of another of his crew, and nearly the lives of the rest of the crew.
Posted by:
Jon Lee on Feb 17, 2015 02:21 PM
Jon Lee on Mount Pilchuck
And what is worse is that they probably made it back to the car ok, reinforcing their bad decision making. I have heard it called the illusion of experience. It is like the captain of the replica of the HMS Bounty, who took his leaky ship out to sea ahead of Superstorm Sandy. His mistaken belief that a "ship is safer at sea" (baloney, a ship is safer nestled in a protected harbour, with her crew ashore sipping hot buttered rums) was reinforced by making similar decisions in the past and surviving. This time through, he lost his ship, his life, the life of another of his crew, and nearly the lives of the rest of the crew.
Posted by:
Jon Lee on Feb 17, 2015 02:21 PM
"Clapping"
Awesome trip report, even better winter hiking rules ;)
Posted by:
Lcassi on Feb 17, 2015 03:26 PM
HYOH
I, too, have encountered more than my fair share of unprepared hikers on Pilchuck and many other trails. I, too, have been concerned for their safety and wondered later that night if they made it back safely. However, I don't think "You are not allowed to go" is the right message to send. On an unseasonably warm February day, these "yokels" decided to spend the day out in the mountains rather than sitting indoors using some form of electronic device. The choice to participate in outdoor recreation should be encouraged for all people, not limited to those who meet a list of criteria. There are so many reasons why those people might have been on the mountain without appropriate gear and attire: lack of education, lack of experience, lack of money, and, yes, there were probably some who just didn't care.
The first hike I went on after moving to Washington was the Boulder River Trail. I was toting my lunch in a Jansport backpack which surely did not contain all 10 essentials, I had Adidas Campuses on my feet, and (gasp) I was wearing a cotton t-shirt. Did I know better gear existed? Yes, but being fresh out of college, I couldn't afford it. Did I fall in the mud several times because of my inadequate footwear and little knowledge of trail conditions? You bet I did. I'm glad that I didn't run into you on the trail that day though, because I surely would have been on the receiving end of your trekking pole pummeling and would have likely felt so bad about myself that I wouldn't have stepped foot on a trail again. Luckily for me, I encountered a lot of really friendly hikers that day. I continued hiking, kept learning more, and my gear choices have improved over time. I now volunteer as a Mountain Steward on some of the most heavily-used trails in the Mount Baker Ranger District so that I can educate other hikers about such topics as the Ten Essentials and appropriate footwear and clothing while still encouraging their interest in hiking. Sometimes they listen and take the advice to heart, and sometimes they don't, but at the end of the day everyone should be given the opportunity to hike their own hike.
Posted by:
ThatsCamping on Feb 17, 2015 05:18 PM
Jon Lee on Mount Pilchuck
Hi Lindsay,
Great input. I really appreciate the thoughtfulness of your response, and agree with a lot of what you said. I made some edits to try to get try to tone down the "you are not allowed to go" vibe. I have to admit that what remains is still heavy handed, but when you see the kind of mass lack-of-awareness that was evident on Mt. Pilchuck on Monday, you come to the conclusion that direct language is warranted.
Let me tell you where I'm coming from. When I first really got into hiking, I too was in tennis shoes, jeans and a little low on gear. I carried water from the start, and very quickly figured out that I needed to carry some extra clothes, first aid, etc. etc. Ditched the jeans the first time I got wet. But the tennis shoes stayed all year. I ended up cover around 160 miles in tennis shoes, on trail all over the state. And I got into some mildly hairy situations, but always either got lucky or exercised good judgement and turned around. I wish to all heck that somebody directly told me early on that the some of the things I was doing, and some of the gear I wasn't carrying was endangering me. I would have really appreciated it. I think it is fair, and helpful to state explicitly that if you are unprepared for the conditions on the trail that you are contemplating, you should not hike it...find somewhere else to go that you are prepared for, or wait for conditions to improve.
When it comes to gear, the cost of entry definitely could be a barrier. I agree that it would be horrible if somebody stayed inside because of it. However, there are many options where the risk is acceptable if you are equipped with tennis shoes, jeans, and a hand-carried water bottle. Discovery Park, Ebey's Landing, Wallace Falls, a slew of busy river hikes. But not on an icy mountain in the winter....it's not worth serious injury or worse.
Posted by:
Jon Lee on Feb 17, 2015 06:47 PM
Jon Lee on Mount Pilchuck
And, further reflecting on your comments, I edited out the pummeling. Though the idea of chasing someone down the trail, poles flailing, shouting "Yokel! Yokel!" is still oddly calming. ;-)
Posted by:
Jon Lee on Feb 17, 2015 07:18 PM
hikinglindsay on Mount Pilchuck
I wholeheartedly agree with you. It is very hard to watch as others put themselves into a dangerous situationwhen there are plenty of safer alternatives. The only point I was trying to make is that, as more experienced hikers, we should be trying to educate hikers for their own safety (knowing that some will completely disregard our message), rather than judge them. Although it didn't come across in the tone of the initial trip report, I can see now that you also want to give others helpful information. Thanks for being open-minded to my feedback. Happy hiking!
Posted by:
ThatsCamping on Feb 17, 2015 08:43 PM